top of page

What Happens If Your Home Is Valued Lower When You Refinance?

8 minutes ago
5 min read

Quick answer: If your home is valued lower than you expect, the share of the property you're borrowing against goes up. That can mean paying lenders mortgage insurance, being offered a higher rate, or not being able to refinance with that lender at all. You usually still have options, and the best time to find out where you stand is before you apply.


Home values across Australia's capital cities have fallen faster this year than at any time in more than 40 years. Cotality's figures show combined capital city values fell 8.1% over seven straight months to October. At the same time, the cash rate rose for the fifth time this year on 3 November, and more people are looking to refinance.


That combination catches people out. You decide to refinance to get a better deal, you apply, and the new lender's valuation comes back lower than you expected. The deal you were chasing isn't there anymore.


Here's how it works, and what you can do about it.


Why does the valuation matter so much when you refinance?


When you refinance, the new lender orders its own valuation of your property. It doesn't use what you paid, what the house down the street sold for, or what an agent told you it might be worth.


That valuation sets your loan-to-value ratio, or LVR: the size of your loan as a share of the property's value. Your LVR decides a lot. It affects whether you'll need lenders mortgage insurance, which rates you're offered, and whether the lender will take the loan on at all.


If the value goes down and the loan stays the same, your LVR goes up, even though you haven't borrowed another dollar.


What happens if the valuation comes in lower than expected?


•     You may cross the 80% line. Most lenders charge lenders mortgage insurance when you borrow more than 80% of the property's value. Crossing that line on a refinance adds a cost you didn't plan for.

•     The rate you were quoted can change. Many lenders price loans by LVR, so a higher LVR can mean a higher rate than the one you were expecting.

•     The lender may say no. If your LVR ends up outside what that lender accepts for a refinance, the application may not go ahead.

•     Equity plans may fall over. If you were planning to release equity for a renovation or to tidy up other debts, there may be less available than you thought.


Who is most likely to be affected right now?


Not everyone. Plenty of owners still have a comfortable amount of equity. The people most exposed tend to be:

•     people who bought or refinanced close to this year's peak, which Cotality puts in February for Sydney and March nationally

•     people who bought with a small deposit

•     owners in markets that have gone sideways for years. Cotality data shows Melbourne values are 7.3% lower than five years ago, and Sydney values are 1.5% below October 2021

•     anyone who has already drawn equity out of their home.


Can you challenge a low valuation?


Sometimes. If you have recent comparable sales that suggest the valuation missed something, a lender may agree to review it or order another one. It isn't guaranteed, and it works best with evidence.


It also helps to know that valuations differ. Lenders use different valuation methods, and a desktop valuation won't always land in the same place as a full inspection. A lower number from one lender doesn't mean every lender will see the property the same way.


What should you do before you apply?


This is where most of the damage can be avoided.


1.     Find out where you stand first. Before an application goes in, a broker can often get a sense of how different lenders are likely to value the property. That's far better than finding out halfway through.

2.     Don't apply in several places at once. Every formal application can show up as an enquiry on your credit file. A string of them in a short time can work against you.

3.     Know your numbers at 80%. Work out what loan size keeps you at or under 80% at a more conservative value, so a lower valuation doesn't come as a shock.

4.     Talk to your current lender too. If moving no longer makes sense, your existing lender may be prepared to review your rate without a new valuation.

5.     Look at the whole loan, not just the rate. Sometimes the better move is restructuring the loan you have rather than switching.


Is it still worth refinancing when values are falling?


For many people, yes. A lower valuation doesn't automatically rule refinancing out. It means the order you do things in matters more. Checking the valuation side first, choosing where to apply, and knowing your fallback options is what separates a refinance that goes smoothly from one that stalls halfway.


Whenever I help someone refinance, we look at how the property is likely to be valued before we look at the rate. If you're thinking about refinancing before Christmas, talk to us first on (02) 9072 9288.


Frequently asked questions


Does a lower valuation mean I've lost money?

Not unless you sell. A valuation is a lender's view of what the property is worth as security for a loan today. It affects what you can borrow against it, not what you owe.


What LVR do I need to avoid lenders mortgage insurance?

Most lenders don't charge lenders mortgage insurance if you borrow 80% or less of the property's value. Some professions and situations have exceptions, so it's worth checking your own case.


Can I ask for a second valuation?

You can ask. Some lenders will review a valuation or order a new one, particularly if you can show recent comparable sales. It isn't guaranteed.


Will applying to refinance affect my credit file?

A formal application usually shows as an enquiry on your credit file. One is rarely a problem. Several in a short period can be, which is why it pays to check where you stand before you apply.


Should I wait for values to recover before refinancing?

Nobody can tell you when values will turn. The better question is what your options are today at a realistic valuation, and what staying where you are is costing you in the meantime.

 

About the author Paul Frazis, Director, George Capital Finance Solutions. Commercial Broker of the Year, Australian Broking Awards 2026. Paul helps home owners and business owners across Australia structure home, business and commercial finance, drawing on years spent on the bank side of the desk.

 

General information only. Not financial advice. George Capital Finance Solutions operates under Connective Credit Services, Australian Credit Licence 389328.

bottom of page